
Last month, a New Jersey Superior Court Judge approved a settlement between AAMHMT Property LLC and Middletown Township. This approval could end the three-year Mount Laurel litigation over the Route 35 Circus Liquors property. File Photo/Emily Schopfer
By Emily Schopfer
MIDDLETOWN – The years-long Mount Laurel litigation between Middletown Township and developer AAMHMT Property LLC over the former Route 35 Circus Liquors site may finally come to an end. At an Oct. 2 fairness hearing, New Jersey Superior Court Judge Gregory L. Acquaviva approved an Aug. 6 settlement agreement allowing 450 residential units on the 52-acre site, possibly resolving the ongoing builder’s remedy lawsuit between the two parties.
Middletown Township made the settlement agreement public Sept. 2. Middletown Township attorney Brian M. Nelson confirmed Nov. 16 that “the court approved the settlement…, which allows for a maximum of 450 total units, including 68 affordable units.”
AAMHMT originally proposed 937 units for the site, which the township opposed. The developer subsequently filed a builder’s remedy lawsuit in August 2023.
The 450 units, as Nelson explained in September to The Two River Times, are not based on the township’s preferences, but on a March 10 report by court-appointed Special Adjudicator Joseph H. Burgis. The report determined that a reasonable level of development would be 485 to 500 units. For more on the development and its history, visit The Two River Times’ website for the Sept. 19 article.
The 68 affordable units would reduce Middletown’s state-mandated affordable housing obligation from 948 to 880. The third round of New Jersey’s affordable housing mandates ended in 2025, and the township had a remaining obligation of 602 units. The fourth round, which will run to 2035, added 346 units. This affordable housing obligation was the crux of AAMHMT’s builder’s remedy, in which the developer claimed the township violated state law by failing to meet its fair share housing obligations.
While the settlement essentially squashes the debate on the number of units, resolving the litigation surrounding the development is more complex. In addition to AAMHMT, the Fair Share Housing Center joined the lawsuit against the township in 2024. The nonprofit organization also joined an April 2023 builder’s remedy lawsuit brought against Middletown by developer Adoni Property Group, LLC, concerning a West Nutswamp Road site.
“All these matters are still docketed, including AAMHMT,” Nelson said. “Until a stipulation of dismissal is filed, they’re still active litigation. There are actions that need to be taken before they are formally dismissed.”
The Adoni Property Group case was dismissed in October 2025, and it “is the only one to have been formally dismissed to date,” Nelson said. The AAMHMT builder’s remedy “is effectively resolved pending implementation under the court’s orders, which requires the adoption of a new redevelopment plan that has been introduced, but not adopted yet,” he said.
The Middletown Township Committee introduced the new redevelopment plan (Ordinance 2026-3544) during the Oct. 19 committee meeting. Mayor Tony Perry, before approving the ordinance, addressed those present at the meeting. “I just want to make sure everyone understands, this is not an approval of any site plans on this property,” he said. “This property would still have to go through planning board applications, site plan review, all those things.” The ordinance was scheduled to undergo public hearing Nov. 9 but was postponed because it did “not get a consistency review from the planning board,” Perry explained during the Nov. 9 committee workshop meeting.
AAHMHT has not issued a project timeline for the development, pending the ordinance.
This article originally appeared in the November 19-25, 2026 print edition of The Two River Times.












