Supporting Players: A Brief History of Thanksgiving Sides

204

Transitional Thanksgiving sides include cranberry sauce, stuffing, corn and green beans. 

By Marirose Krall

The Pilgrims weren’t lacking options at their first feast of thanksgiving, but they did have to rely on what was available nearby – and marshmallow-laced sweet potatoes were most certainly not on the menu. Still, in the four centuries since Myles Standish dined on eels, venison and corn porridge, Americans have created a distinct lineup of side dishes that include many holiday classics inspired by that inaugural meal. 

Origins of Old Favorites

 “Native winter squash and pumpkins (referred to as pompions) were boiled, stewed, or roasted rather than baked into pies,” according to Megan Gambino in Smithsonian Magazine (“What Food was Served at the First Thanksgiving in 1621,” November 26, 2024). The meal also included “local chestnuts, walnuts, dried blueberries and currants.” Squash, pumpkin and assorted nuts continue to be associated with the modern Thanksgiving menu, underscoring the importance of tradition on this holiday. 


A home economist at the Campbell Soup Company developed the green bean casserole. The recipe was printed on the label of the company’s mushroom soup cans.

Unsurprisingly, more recent additions to the Thanksgiving roster gained popularity with the help of clever marketing campaigns. Green bean casserole, for example, made its way into the mainstream in 1955 when Dorcas Reilly (coincidentally, the bearer of a first name very popular with the Pilgrims), a home economist for the Campbell Soup Company, developed the recipe. It was printed on the label of the company’s mushroom soup cans and the dish caught on quickly. Likewise, marshmallow-topped sweet potato casserole was invented by the marketing team at the Angelus Marshmallow company. The firm hired cookbook writer Janet McKenzie Hill to create a pamphlet of marshmallow-based recipes.

Canned cranberry sauce had a somewhat less commercial beginning. It was originated by attorney and cranberry farmer Marcus L. Urann in 1912, who wanted a way to preserve the fruit beyond its short season.

“Thanksgiving sides are interesting,” said Mike McDonald, vice president of Delicious Orchards in Colts Neck. “They carry a lot of nostalgia and memories with them. That’s why so many people – myself included – must have the classics: stuffing, mashed potatoes and cranberry sauce, both canned and fresh.”

And while many of us remember with wry fondness the plunk of canned cranberry sauce dropping onto a plate in all its tin-grooved glory, unprocessed trimmings continue to rise in popularity. “It seems like there has been a resurgence in the value of fresh ingredients and making things from scratch: classics like stuffed artichokes, roasted Brussels sprouts and cauliflower. A lot of younger customers are turning to these again,” McDonald said. 


While some still cling to canned cranberry sauce the way it clings to the can, a homemade version can be used in many ways, from a topping to a dip.

Twists on Tradition

The idea of reworking those old favorites has also gained popularity. “A trend we’ve seen is using cranberry sauce as a dip; think for potato skins or crunchy app bites. I’m 100% in on this one as cranberry sauce can’t get enough love,” McDonald said.

In addition, “Mushrooms are having their moment to shine. People are doing some unique things with them. They’ve always had a place at the table, but they’re starting to take center stage. We have a recipe that calls for stuffing them with squash and quinoa. It’s a game changer!” (See sidebar.)

McDonald plans to incorporate another adapted version of a classic at his own holiday table. “In our house, we’re going to try some butternut squash mac and cheese.”

What will you include at your house – a new spin on stuffing? A reinvention of the roll? A fresh perspective on pie? Consider that the most memorable feasts may include a mouth-watering blend of tried-and-true recipes and new discoveries to elevate and enhance the Thanksgiving table.


Autumn Harvest Stuffed Portobello Mushrooms


Stuffed portobello mushrooms represent a new take on a Thanksgiving side. Courtesy Delicious Orchards

Ingredients

5-6 portobello mushrooms

1 cup quinoa

1 pound sausage (no fennell)

1 cup butternut squash, diced

1/2 cup dried cranberries

1/2 cup walnuts, chopped

1/4 cup onion, chopped

2 cloves garlic, minced

1 tablespoon fresh thyme leaves

1/2 cup Parmesan cheese, grated

2 tablespoons olive oil

Salt and pepper, to taste

2 cups vegetable broth or water

Instructions

Preheat your oven to 375°F and line a baking sheet with parchment paper.

Clean the portobello mushrooms, remove the stems and scrape out the gills. Brush with olive oil and season with salt and pepper.

Cook quinoa in a vegetable broth or water until fluffy, about
15 minutes.

Cook sausage and set aside.

Sauté the butternut squash in olive oil until tender, then add onion, garlic and thyme.

Combine the cooked sausage, quinoa, sautéed squash, cranberries and walnuts in a bowl.

Stuff the mushroom caps with the quinoa mixture and top with parmesan cheese.

Bake for 20-25 minutes until the mushrooms are tender and the cheese is melted and golden.

Let cool for a few minutes before serving.

Recipe courtesy Delicious Orchards

This article originally appeared in the November 19-25, 2026 print edition of The Two River Times.