County Gives NY Waterway 30 Days to Improve Belford Ferry Service

94
During an Oct. 23 ride to Belford from Brookfield Place in New York, a passenger who did not want to give his last name witnessed the door to a life jacket closet fall off a NY Waterway ferry and be taped back up by crew members. The incident occurred the day after Monmouth County announced its plans for a 30-day ultimatum for NY Waterway to improve service. Provided By Ferry Passenger 

By Emily Schopfer

MIDDLETOWN – Starting Nov. 1, Monmouth County Commissioner Director Thomas A. Arnone gave NY Waterway 30 days to “demonstrate substantial and sustained improvements” or risk contract termination, according to an Oct. 22 statement. The 30-day ultimatum stems from an incident the morning of Oct. 6, when a Manhattan-bound ferry, the Molly Pitcher, struck a piling as it departed from the Belford terminal, breaking several windows.
No passengers or crew were injured during the incident and the ferry continued its journey to New York. But local and county officials quickly expressed concern over how NY Waterway handled the incident; both Arnone and Middletown Mayor Tony Perry released statements the same day.
“While no injuries have been reported, this is still a very serious matter,”Perry said.
“Let me make this clear,” Arnone said in his initial statement, “my fellow County Commissioners and I are completely appalled by the way NY Waterway handled this morning’s incident at the Belford Ferry Terminal. Equally concerning is the fact that the county learned about the incident from ferry passengers rather than directly from NY Waterway.”
Arnone cited concern that proper procedure was not followed post-incident, including notification to the U.S. Coast Guard, and said an investigation would be conducted.  

County Ultimatum

“We have been assured by NY Waterway that all of the concerns will be addressed in a consistent manner moving forward. While we are hopeful that NY Waterway will fulfill its contractual obligations, we will continue to hold them accountable,” Arnone said in the Oct. 22 statement. “We have agreed to give NY Waterway 30 days, beginning November 1, to demonstrate substantial and sustained improvements. If NY Waterway fails to meet all contractual obligations, we will move forward with terminating the contract.”
NY Waterway operated from the Belford terminal until Seastreak assumed operation in December 2022, according to a Dec. 2, 2022, Two River Times article. NY Waterway repurchased the ferry contract in September 2026, according to an Aug. 14 Monmouth County news release.
NY Waterway has not released a formal statement about the county’s demand but did send an Oct. 27 letter to passengers. Armand Pohan, the president and CEO of NY Waterway, did not explicitly mention the Oct. 6 incident or county ultimatum in the letter. He instead acknowledged issues with service timing, saying “dredging and bulkhead work being performed in the Belford channel… is slowing up the ferryboats by up to 2 minutes each way.” Additional congestion at Brookfield in New York and work at Pier 11 are also to blame for delays in ferry schedules, according to the letter.
The letter was shared with The Two River Times by frequent Belford ferry rider and Middletown resident, Matt Christensen. Christensen is one of the signers of a petition called “Return Seastreak Ferry Service to Belford.” The petition was started by Middletown’s Janine Materna.  

Service ‘Pattern’

“An unrealistic schedule, boats in poor condition, a stretched workforce – and then, when a safety incident happened on its own boat, said nothing publicly about it,” Christensen said. “The incident was one day; the lack of preparation and accountability is the pattern. And the fact that they just continued on to NYC while passengers were covered in glass, with no acknowledgment to date, is wild.”
While not a passenger on the Molly Pitcher Oct. 6, Christensen said he was a passenger on the 8 a.m. boat that followed it. “I reached out to friends who take that ferry and heard all about it,” he said. Christensen also contacted the Coast Guard about the incident. “They were shocked to hear it had not been reported to them by NY Waterway,” he said.
This was not the first time Christensen, who uses the ferry about three times a week to commute into work at Hudson Yards, has contacted the U.S. Coast Guard with concerns. Before the Molly Pitcher was in operation, “they had folks packed into their smaller vessels. As someone who holds boating certifications and licenses, I can say they were 100% over capacity limits – forcing people to sit on the floor and in the staircases, while most were braving the outside, even in the rain, just to find a place to stand,” he said. He reached out to the Coast Guard asking them to investigate the issue.
Christensen has used the ferry as his exclusive mode of transport for work since 2023, and said since the September transition to NY Waterway, “the service has felt noticeably less reliable.” He noted how “late boats and missed connections” have become routine. “That steady unreliability is what had riders frustrated well before Oct. 6,” he said.
Switching to Seastreak, which still operates from Atlantic Highlands and Highlands, is not an option for him, Christiansen said, as Belford offers the only route that gets him to West 39th Street near his job. “I don’t have the luxury of switching operators or terminals. I need this one to be safe and reliable. Belford is how this community gets to work.”
Christensen supports the county’s decision to issue an ultimatum. “For Leonardo and Middletown, it’s not a convenience; it’s infrastructure: jobs, family schedules and the decision to live here at all are built around that boat. If people can’t trust it to be safe – let alone on time – the whole community pays for it.”
Another passenger, Jack H., who asked not to share his last name, is a New York resident who rides the Belford Ferry about twice a week. Having only ever ridden the ferry when Seastreak owned and operated it, Jack said he initially thought NY Waterway “can’t be that bad.” Since Seastreak and NY Waterway are essentially a “duopoly,” they should be “neck and neck from a quality perspective,” he said. But, in his experience, that has not been the case.
NY Waterway does not offer the options that Seastreak did, such as the shuttle service between terminals, he said. Travelers are also “paying a premium” to choose NY Waterway over other means of travel such as NJ Transit, he said. Jack also signed the petition to return Seastreak service to Belford.
While not a rider on the Molly Pitcher Oct. 6, Jack said he was on the ferry the day prior when an engine stalled, stranding passengers on the trip to New York for about 15 minutes. There was “no announcement, just puttering” from the engine, he said.
In another instance, as the ferry departed from Brookfield, Jack said he saw the door of a closet housing lifejackets fall off and into the aisle. Luckily, no one was hit by the door, he said. Eventually, crew members “literally taped the door” shut, he said, which was concerning because, “What happens in the event of an emergency?” he wondered. Jack rode on the same boat Monday, Oct. 26, and said the door was still taped up.
While it is “great that they’re taking action,” referring to the county, Jack said he does not understand why NY Waterway was given 30 days instead of being held accountable at the time of the incidents.  

Changes Ahead

According to NY Waterway’s Oct. 27 letter, they were adding trips from Belford terminal starting the morning of Nov. 2 – one at 5:15 a.m. Monday departing Belford and another departing Pier 79 at 6:15 p.m. Monday evening. This trip will continue “to Brookfield and Pier 11 in the same manner as the present 6:15 p.m. trip that has been running Tuesday through Thursday.”
The letter also says the 6:30 a.m. trip from Belford will depart 10 minutes earlier, at 6:20 a.m.
“We have opened several dozen ferry services over the years, but this has been the most difficult in part because we have replaced an incumbent who had some very loyal supporters,” the letter read. “Nonetheless, we are working very hard to improve our performance and to deliver to you a safe, consistent and reliable service.”

This article originally appeared in the November 5-11, 2026 print edition of The Two River Times.