Former Sickles Property May Be Slated for 20 Homes

89

The owners of 1663 Market are planning a 20-unit residential development on the property at Harrison Avenue in Little Silver. File photo/Sunayana Prabhu


By Sunayana Prabhu

LITTLE SILVER – 1663 Market, the shuttered gourmet food store that replaced Sickles Market, may be transformed into residential housing, the former mayor confirmed. 

The owners are planning a residential community on the property, Bob Neff Jr. said in an interview. The proposal is for 20 residential units; four will be affordable, and the rest will be market-rate, single-family homes. The plans are not fully developed and have not been officially submitted to the borough. 

The proposal would include part of the Harrison Avenue property, including the former Sickles Market buildings, an existing house, greenhouses, the parking lot and the nursery sales area, Neff said. He stressed that the plans were still informal.

“We don’t have any formal application,” Neff said. “Nobody’s come to the planning board. Nobody’s come to the council yet.”

Neff said the owners had kept borough officials informed as a courtesy. As far as officials knew, he said, there was no proposal to build on the back of the property. 

Any formal application would require public hearings, and the timing would be up to the developer.

The site had been home to Sickles Market, a family-run business that served the community for generations before closing in 2024 amid bankruptcy proceedings. Its sudden closure left employees unpaid and customers with gift cards they could not redeem. 

Three Rumson residents – Dennis Devine, Jennifer Karp and Timothy McCooey – reopened the store in August 2025 as 1663 Market, named for the year the land was first settled and deeded. However, the revival was short-lived; the store closed Jan. 18, 2026. 

“It is with deep disappointment that we announce the closing of 1663 Market,” the owners said in a joint statement posted on social media in January. They said the decision stemmed from a lack of sustained community support and lingering negativity from the prior business’s failure, which made the operation unsustainable.

Despite efforts to rebuild trust – paying former employees, honoring Sickles’ gift cards and retaining knowledgeable staff – the market struggled to gain traction.

“It is sad that our thoughtful community-driven vision will not come to light. Please know we will do our best to help shape the next chapter in a positive direction,” the owners said in a joint statement Jan. 18.

In October 2025, Devine told The Two River Times that saving Sickles wasn’t just about nostalgia; it was also about safeguarding a property “from a development that would no longer include the market and would have been terribly impactful to the community.” 

Devine did not return requests for information about the proposed development by press time.

Although a formal plan has not been presented to the borough, Neff estimated that a council presentation might come within a couple of months, depending on the developer.

Neff, who resigned after 15 years as mayor, said development pressures and affordable-housing requirements have led Little Silver to approve some higher-density housing. He said the borough’s population has remained near 6,000 and that the town’s overall character has stayed much the same. 

This article originally appeared in the November 19-25, 2026 print edition of The Two River Times.